5 Thanksgiving leftover mistakes you might be making
One of the best parts about Thanksgiving isn’t the meal itself – it’s the leftovers. But before you reach for round two, make sure you aren’t making some common leftover mistakes that could affect the safety, quality or simply leave you tired of turkey by the weekend.
Lindsay Fencl, a registered dietitian at Aurora Health Care, shares five mistakes to avoid so you can make the most of your Thanksgiving leftovers.
Mistake 1: Leaving food out too long
Although it’s nice to linger around the table after Thanksgiving dinner, don’t forget about the food sitting on the kitchen counter. Take a second to pack up or put away the leftovers so they don’t spoil.
“Perishable foods should be refrigerated within two hours of being served,” says Fencl. “To help leftovers cool quickly and evenly, divide large portions into shallow containers before refrigerating them.”
Mistake 2: Not reheating leftovers thoroughly
Just because your plate feels warm after taking it out of the microwave doesn’t mean all your food has reached a safe temperature.
“When reheating leftovers, make sure the internal temperature reaches 165 degrees Fahrenheit,” Fencl says. “Gravies, soups and sauces should be brought to a rolling boil before serving again.”
Fencl also recommends covering food to help retain moisture and stirring or rotating it halfway through reheating to eliminate cold spots.
Mistake 3: Keeping leftovers for too long
By Monday, that container of turkey in the refrigerator may still look perfectly fine. But looks, smells and even taste aren’t actually reliable ways to determine whether leftovers are safe.
In fact, Fencl says Thanksgiving foods should only be stored in the refrigerator for three to four days.
“If you don’t anticipate eating your leftovers within that timeframe, consider sharing them with family or friends or freezing them for later,” she says. “When in doubt, throw it out. Harmful
bacteria aren’t always visible, detectable by smell or noticeable by taste.”
Mistake 4: Waiting too long to freeze them
Not feeling up for more turkey in the days after Thanksgiving? Try freezing it right away.
Many Thanksgiving staples freeze well and maintain good quality for three to six months when properly stored, Fencl says. For the best results, freeze leftovers within the first few days after Thanksgiving rather than waiting until they’re about to reach the end of their refrigerator life.
“Portion leftovers into individual or family-sized containers and label each container with the contents and date,” Fencl says. “Using airtight freezer bags or containers can also help prevent freezer burn and preserve freshness.”
Turkey, stuffing, gravy, mashed potatoes, sweet potato casserole, soups and homemade turkey broth are all good candidates for the freezer. Cream-based dishes, including casseroles and pies, may become watery or change texture after freezing and reheating.
Mistake 5: Eating the same plate over and over
Food safety isn’t the only reason Thanksgiving leftovers end up in the trash. Eventually you get tired of eating the same foods for the fourth day in a row.
Instead of reheating the same meal, Fencl recommends turning leftovers into something new. She suggests trying a few of these ideas to give the holiday staples a second life:
- Turkey: Add it to cranberry turkey sandwiches or wraps, noodle soup, chili, quesadillas, pot pie or fried rice.
- Mashed potatoes: Turn them into potato pancakes, waffles or soup, or use them as a topping for shepherd’s pie.
- Stuffing: Repurpose it into breakfast muffins or waffles or use it as a flavorful casserole topping.
- Cranberry sauce: Mix it into yogurt or oatmeal, blend it into a smoothie or add it to sandwiches, pancakes or waffles.
- Roasted vegetables: Toss them into soup, salads, grain bowls, omelets or frittatas.
However you give your Thanksgiving favorites a second life, following a few food safety basics can help make sure those leftovers are as safe as they are delicious.
Do you want expert care for minor health concerns and ongoing conditions from the comfort of home? A virtual primary care provider may be right for you. Learn more: IL | WI
Related Posts
Comments
About the Author
health enews contributor, is on the digital content team at Advocate Health and has been writing for over 15 years. She’s covered everything from health care to tech and explored topics that dive into the patient, provider and payer perspectives. When not writing, you can find her lounging at the beach or walking around the world at Walt Disney World’s EPCOT.













