How do you pick a doctor? Here are 5 tips

How do you pick a doctor? Here are 5 tips

Choosing a doctor can be a daunting task. You need someone you can trust with your life, someone who will see things in your health and history that you don’t and someone you can talk openly and honestly with.

“A good doctor is someone you can communicate with, who is on your side, listens to you and your needs and tries to find the best path for you,” says Dr. Reena Shah, an internal medicine doctor at Advocate Health Care. “They will look out for your best interests.”

A primary care doctor is the coordinator of your care, like the conductor in an orchestra who puts all the different pieces together, she says.

Dr. Shah says there are five things anyone should keep in mind when in the market for a new primary care doctor:

1. Suit your needs

You’ll need to think about what type of doctor will best fit your individual and family health needs. There are several medical specialties and board certifications to choose from:

    • Family medicine — Family practitioners are highly trained general medical practitioners who may provide medical, gynecological, pediatric and sometimes even surgical care for patients of any age. These doctors treat illnesses, provide preventive care and coordinate the care that may be provided by other specialty care physicians and health professionals.
    • Internal medicine — Typically, internal medicine physicians, or internists, are trained to treat any medical conditions that are not surgical or gynecological. Internists may also provide primary care for young adults, adults and seniors, providing preventive care and coordinating care with other medical specialists.
    • Pediatrician — Pediatricians are trained to care for the specific needs of growing infants, children and teenagers.
    • Geriatrics – Geriatric doctors, or geriatricians, specialize in the care of aging adults who are 65 and older who often require complex care and medication.
    • Integrative medicine – These physicians combine conventional medicine with complementary therapies to help take care of the whole person.

2. Ask for recommendations

One of the best resources for a new doctor can be your own circle of family members and friends. In addition, the insurance coverage you’re considering will determine who you have to choose from. Coverage may vary doctor to doctor, so be certain to make sure any doctor you’re considering accepts your insurance coverage.

3. Well-connected

A physician’s hospital affiliation may also be valuable to know in the event you need more serious care. Choosing a provider with a strong relationship with a reputable hospital provides access to specialties like cardiovascular care, cancer treatment and surgical services, if needed.

4. Location, location, location

Having a doctor whose office is close to your work will help ensure you make your regular appointments and make it easier to get into the office when you’re not feeling well. Also, check to make certain the office is open when you need it. Many physician practices not only offer expanded evening and weekend hours, but allow other practice physicians to see you if your chosen physician isn’t available.

5. In tune

Like any long-term relationship, your relationship with your primary care physician is ultimately based on trust and compatibility. Check language preferences, education and seriously consider if this is someone you can speak with openly. You’ll need to be able to communicate openly and directly with your physician, so make certain you’re completely comfortable with them.

“Seeing your primary care doctor regularly can help prevent minor issues from becoming major, and help you keep on top of existing health concerns,” Dr. Shah says. “It’s important that you put care and thought into the decision and, hopefully, build a lasting relationship with your doctor. You want to find someone you can grow old with.”

Are you trying to find a doctor? Look here if you live in Illinois. Look here if you live in Wisconsin.

Related Posts



  1. Dr. Barbara Edwards (Princeton) January 18, 2018 at 8:33 am · Reply

    Finding a doctor that’s well connected to reputable hospital should be one of the deciding factors when looking for a new physician. Thanks for these tips.

  2. I like your tip about choosing a primary care physician whose clinic is near my workplace or home to ensure I would make my regular appointments. My husband and I are looking for a primary care doctor that could take both of us. We want to find one who’s friendly and reliable, so thanks for the tips!

  3. Charlotte Serazio February 22, 2022 at 1:21 pm · Reply

    You overlooked Geriatrician, a doctor who specialises in care of the elderly and the diseases that affect them.
    Also, a good point of reference for finding a new physician would be to ask a physician whom you have been presently happy with who they would refer themselves to or their family members, albeit to another specialty, i.e., gynecology, neurologist, gastrointestinal and so forth. I have found this to be the best source for finding a new doctor. Also, ask your doctor himself prior to his retirement whom he would refer within his own speciality!

  4. How do you “stop in and meet a physician you’re considering” without scheduling an appointment to receive care? Should you expect to be billed for this meeting, which won’t be insurance reimbursable? Should you expect to wait several months for the next available appointment for this meeting, and then wait several more months for the next available new patient office visit appointment for care after that meeting?

  5. Sorry but it is my tendency to avoid all medical unless it is a dire necessity!

Subscribe to health enews newsletter

About the Author

health enews Staff
health enews Staff

health enews staff is a group of experienced writers from our Advocate Health Care and Aurora Health Care sites, which also includes freelance or intern writers.