Why does that guy give you the creeps?

Why does that guy give you the creeps?

It’s lunch time at the office and you are trapped in a conversation with the creepy guy at the coffee machine. He makes you nervous, even makes your skin crawl, but can you explain why? Is it how he talks? Dresses? Smells? New research from Knox College in Galesburg, Ill., offers an explanation for the “creep factor.”

Researchers created a survey to gauge the characteristics of creepiness and received more than 1,300 responses. Participants were asked to rate stereotypically creepy physical qualities and behaviors on a scale of one to five in terms of creepiness. They found anxiety—or “being creeped out”—was triggered by the uncertainty of whether there was something to fear in a person. When being around someone creepy, people felt discomfort because they didn’t know whether or not the person was a threat.

“Only when we are confronted with uncertainty about a threat do we get ‘creeped out.’ Our uncertainty paralyzes us about how to respond,” said Frank McAndrew, the study’s lead researcher, in Psychology Today.

The survey also tested what people found to be the most creepy, unpredictable behaviors and characteristics. The findings show that general abnormality was ranked highest on the creepy scale. Smiling peculiarly, laughing at inappropriate times, bulging eyes, long fingers, pasty skin, greasy hair or dark bags under the eyes also ranked high. When researchers looked at what people considered the ‘creepiest’ occupations: taxidermists, funeral directors and sex shop workers topped the list.

“We are hardwired in our biology to assess features,” says Nisa Johnson, a licensed clinical social worker with Advocate Medical Group in Bloomington, Ill. “So when we see greasy hair, long fingers, or pale skin, it can be viewed as signs of ill health.”

A person’s unusual features set off alarm bells in the brain and, for lack of better label, they are characterized as creepy, Johnson explains.

The study also found females were far more likely to perceive creepiness than males. Bryan DeNure, a licensed clinical professional counselor with Advocate Medical Group theorizes that this is because “women are more often victims of sexual assault and domestic battery at the hands of men and as a result, it is a logical conclusion that women are socially trained to be more aware of these things.” Women are generally described as more intuitive and therefore may be more perceptive to the threat of “creepiness,” DeNure adds.

So being “creeped out” is actually a natural reaction to abnormality. While there may be no real threat from the creepy guy at work, your instincts actively guard you nevertheless.

Related Posts



  1. Lois Strzyzewski June 27, 2016 at 11:46 am · Reply

    How sad. Physical features that no one could help considered creepy? Something good might be overlooked. What about someone in a wheel chair?
    Greasy hair could be changed.
    Funeral home director creepy? Don’t visit when someone dies then.

    This must be a survey of those who are shallow. Try this for creepy. Not respecting a healthy boundry and cruelty. A polished turd. My advice for the young

  2. Brian L Wishnefsky December 20, 2016 at 4:53 pm · Reply

    Doesn’t this strike you as strange that some Mental Health Experts who have people who believe whatever they say because it is suppose to be Scientific to judge other people as Creepy or not?

    How about their Professions?

    Who died & left them in Charge?

    Is this Really Science?

    Does this contribute to the betterment of Society?

    If you lacked social Social skills could a mean-spirited person use this against you?

    I don’t know about you but this reminds me of High School for some reason.

  3. I disagree about the physical traits creeping people out that much, it’s really the vibes they give off

Subscribe to health enews newsletter

About the Author

health enews Staff
health enews Staff

health enews staff is a group of experienced writers from our Advocate Health Care and Aurora Health Care sites, which also includes freelance or intern writers.